58 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The next evening, Tally and Shay find Zane and a group of Crims gathered by the river, as if they were runaways. After the attack on the Armory, the authorities are out in force, so Tally and Shay warn the group to be extra careful—though they do not tell them that they will be following them in order to find the New Smoke. First, they must free Zane of his tracking collar. He requests that Tally be the one to do it. Once he is freed of the device, he and his fellow Crims release their collars and wristbands into the sky on balloons.
Zane again urges Tally to break the bonds of whatever has been done to her brain in the process of becoming Special, but she does not want to do so. She likes being Special, and she wants Zane to join her. He wants her to make up her own mind about which side she fights for. Finally, Zane and the others leave while Tally and Shay trail invisibly behind in their sneak suits.
Tally watches over the group carefully; she worries about Zane and his weakness, and she wants to keep him safe. The wild can be dangerous. Shay is much less concerned, so she sends Tally to check on them, and Tally discovers that there are nine people gathered rather than the eight that left. When the group leaves the area, Shay follows Zane and the Crims, while Tally tracks the ninth figure who goes off in a different direction. She ambushes the young man who turns to look at her. He knows her name.
The man is Andrew Simpson Smith, who Tally once met when she was a young Ugly, running away into the wild. He is from one of the villages trapped in the world outside the cities, living like “pre-Rusties, wearing skins and using only Stone Age tools” (144). The authorities believed these people could pose a danger to others, so they keep them contained by electronic means—until Tally stumbled upon a group of villagers who introduced her to Smith. She tried to convince the holy man that the villagers were kept in place by technology controlled by outsiders. Apparently, he eventually believed her because he now travels the wild on his own—after setting fire to the perimeters of his village.
Smith is now allied with the Smokies, and the groups are all intent on setting the various populations free. To Tally, this sounds like a dangerous proposition. Smith has a position-finder that will lead her to the New Smoke. However, Smith is also now suspicious of Tally; the Specials are feared in the villages as ferocious enforcers. He asks if she still questions the “gods” of the city. She does not wish to lie to him; she has respect for him, in his survival skills. She answers in the affirmative. She silently acknowledges that getting Zane back is more important to her than defeating the Smokies. He hands over the position-finder.
Tally struggles with whether to tell Shay about the position-finder. She thinks of cutting herself to gain clarity of thought but ultimately decides against it—Zane would not approve. She tells Shay the truth.
Shay discovers that the position-finder only gives one waypoint at a time; one must reach that destination before it points to the next. She does not want to waste any more time following Zane’s group, but Tally refuses to leave them. She reasons that it would be safer for both of them—and for the overall plan—if they split up. Shay believes that Tally is making decisions based on her feelings for Zane. Shay finally agrees, but she is furious with Tally, saying she no longer cares what Tally does. Tally firmly believes that she is taking the right path, regardless of what Shay or the Cutters think of her.
Tally keeps a close watch over Zane and the Crims. They are inept in the wild, making a fire that leaves behind a trail of smoke. Tally decides to set an alarm to wake her every 10 minutes in order to check on their progress. At one point, she sees a flash of metal in the sun: The group has left their hoverboards out to charge, but the light glinting against the metal acts like a beacon. Tally carefully approaches the hoverboards, allowing her sneak suit to help her blend into the background. She tries to make it appear as if the boards have been blown by the wind into a heap. As she goes to leave, she hears a sound behind her: Zane has awakened and come to investigate. Tally whispers that he is having a dream, but she worries that he knows someone is following them.
The journey is slow, and Tally worries that Shay will already have found the New Smoke, that the Specials will be waiting to ambush Zane’s group as soon as they arrive. Nevertheless, Tally enjoys her time spent in nature, where Cutters were meant to be. One morning, she finds another hoverboard in the sun and works to move it, but it is anchored down by something. When she turns, she finds Zane waiting to talk to her.
They move away from the group, and Zane thanks her for looking after them. He also notices that she is changing, probably from her time spent free in the wild. For her part, she still sees, in painful detail, the weakness in Zane’s body. Zane reminds her about David, who had called Tally beautiful even before she had the operation to make her pretty. He tries to shame her for being repulsed by his own frailty. He kisses her, and Tally reacts with undisguised disgust. Almost immediately, however, she is distraught over her reaction and flees. She will continue to watch over him and the group, but she will keep her distance.
The journey seems even longer after this incident, and Tally continues to berate herself for her reaction to Zane. The group starts to worry about their supplies holding out as they continue to search for the New Smoke. At their next stop, there is evidence that other people have been here, and Tally worries that the villagers might be roaming this area. Their typical reaction to outsiders is not friendly, so Tally keeps herself awake as the group sleeps. Another group arrives at the campsite within hours.
The changes in Tally are hastened by her exposure to the wild, which reminds her of the Freedom and Responsibility of living in nature. In contrast to the tightly controlled confines of the city, the wild teems with unpredictability rather than government-approved activities. Technology, and the enhancements it offers, seems less significant in the context of the wider world. She knows that she is “changing again,” as she begins to feel less Special in the wild, disconnected from her fellow Cutters. Zane notices these changes as soon as he talks with her, near the end of their journey towards the New Smoke. Though he is encouraged by these changes, Tally is less certain of how she feels. She worries that she is now “nothing but what other people have done to [her]—a big collection of brainwashing, surgeries, and cures” (177). Thus, Tally still struggles with her own identity, and with whose side she wants to support in turn.
She continues to uphold the status quo, as policed by Dr. Cable and other city authorities. She agrees to Shay’s plan to track Zane and his group for two reasons at odds with one another. On the one hand, she fulfills her duty as a Special by finding the New Smoke and leading the charge against them and their nano pills; the city will remain unchanged and protected. On the other hand, her concern for Zane eclipses her programmed responses; she would rather save him than the city. Her internal conflict of Appearances Versus Autonomy culminates in wanting Zane to become a Special, too. She is choosing to break the rules to “help” him and possibly rekindle their relationship, which indicates autonomy, but she does so only because she is so beholden to the implanted superiority complex of Specials that she cannot bear to be with him as he is. The preoccupation with physical perfection, instilled in Uglies as children before they receive the mind-altering Pretty surgery, has only been further enhanced by Tally’s Special status.
Tally’s meeting with Andrew Simpson Smith, a villager even further removed from her idea of “civilization” than the Smokies, also stokes this internal battle. When she thinks of Smith and his fellow villagers out in the wild and allied with the Smokies, she is disturbed: “The Smokies had really gone crazy now, letting a bunch of deadly savages out in the wild. Of course, the villagers would make useful allies” (148). Warfare is one of these fearful skills of villagers, something that appears to be a valid concern for Tally. The idea that the Smokies and the villagers might sow violence in their quest to free people from government control upends Tally’s worldview, wherein the authorities keep ordinary civilians safe from their own worst impulses. Yet, she admires Smith enough to be honest with him: “Living in the wild had made him more like her: a hunter, a warrior, a survivor. With the scars of a dozen fights and accidents, he almost looked like a Cutter” (151). Whether her respect is borne of a Special’s respect for physical prowess or of more human empathy, it prompts her to realize, for the first time since her transition to being Special, that she is not entirely apart from others. This crack in her sense of isolation, and thus her identity, indicates she is not totally allied to the authorities.
This is not merely the result of her exposure to the wild. As discussed in the previous section, it is also the result of encountering Zane, who acts as her proxy conscience. For example, she quits cutting herself because Zane disapproves of self-harm. However, her development is most significantly the result of Tally’s own internal sense of self and strength, rather than being Special. As she begins to understand, “The Cutters might be Specials, but over the last few days Tally Youngblood had reverted to her own nature: thoroughly Crim” (151-52). That is, she continues to return to herself, to trust her own instincts regardless of her programming. She works around the rewiring to remember her true self, the “Crim” who disregards the corrupt powers that try to control her.
Plus, gain access to 9,100+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Scott Westerfeld