49 pages • 1 hour read
SuperFreakonomics: Global Cooling, Patriotic Prostitutes, and Why Suicide Bombers Should Buy Life Insurance
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Chapter 4Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Chapter 4 Summary: “The Fix Is In: And it’s Cheap and Simple”
Content Warning: This section of the guide contains discussions of maternal mortality.
The chapter begins with the story of Ignaz Semmelweis, a Hungarian physician in the mid-19th century who confronted the rampant issue of childbed fever in maternity wards. Semmelweis observed that women attended by doctors and medical students had significantly higher mortality rates compared to those attended by midwives. Through meticulous observation, he deduced that doctors were transferring infectious material from autopsies to the maternity ward. By implementing a simple hand-washing protocol using a chlorinated solution, Semmelweis drastically reduced mortality rates. However, despite the clear success of this intervention, Semmelweis faced resistance from the medical community. The authors use this example to assert that entrenched beliefs can impede the adoption of effective solutions.
The narrative then shifts to the introduction of seat belts in automobiles. While seat belts have undoubtedly saved lives by reducing fatalities in car accidents, their introduction also led to an unintended consequence known as risk compensation. Some drivers, feeling more secure, began to drive more recklessly, potentially offsetting the safety benefits of seat belts. This phenomenon underscores the complexity of human behavior and how safety measures can sometimes lead to riskier actions.
Levitt and Dubner then explore the unintended effects of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Intended to protect disabled workers from discrimination, the ADA made it more challenging for employers to dismiss employees with disabilities. As a result, some employers became hesitant to hire disabled workers because they wished to avoid potential legal complications; the authors contend that the implementation of the ADA inadvertently reduced employment opportunities for the very group that the legislation aimed to help.
The authors also discuss how environmental regulations such as the Endangered Species Act can lead to counterproductive behaviors. Landowners, upon discovering that their property is a habitat for endangered species, might preemptively alter the land to make it uninhabitable for the species in question, thereby avoiding restrictions on land use. This approach illustrates that protective legislation for endangered species can sometimes incentivize harmful actions against the species it seeks to protect.
They next explain the unintended consequences of Prohibition in the United States. The ban on alcohol was intended to reduce crime and improve public morals, but instead, it led to a surge in illegal activities, including bootlegging and the rise of organized crime. The authors cite this example to demonstrate that prohibitive measures can create black markets and exacerbate the problems they aim to solve. To emphasize this, Levitt and Dubner introduce the concept of the “Cobra Effect,” named after an incident during British colonial rule in India. To reduce the number of dangerous cobras, the government offered a bounty for every dead cobra. Enterprising individuals began breeding cobras in order to collect the bounty. When the government realized what was happening and canceled the program, the breeders released the now-worthless cobras, causing an abrupt increase in the cobra population.
In exploring innovative solutions, the chapter highlights a proposal to mitigate hurricanes by deploying simple, cost-effective devices in the ocean that disrupt the formation of these storms. The idea involves using large tubes to bring cold water from the depths to the surface, thereby reducing sea surface temperatures and preventing hurricanes from gaining strength.
The authors then emphasize the importance of thoroughly analyzing potential outcomes before implementing solutions to complex problems. Using the examples of Semmelweis and the hurricane mitigation strategies, the authors advocate for a comprehensive approach that considers human behavior, incentives, and the possibility of unintended consequences, urging policymakers and individuals alike to think both critically and holistically when devising interventions.
Chapter 4 Analysis
By examining Ignaz Semmelweis’s 19th-century handwashing intervention, the authors demonstrate that entrenched professional norms and cognitive biases can act as obstacles to beneficial change. Despite clear data showing reduced mortality rates, the medical community’s reluctance to accept Semmelweis’s findings shows how deeply human behavior is tied to social and professional incentives. Accepting Semmelweis’s solution would have required doctors to confront their own role in spreading disease and harming their patients—an acknowledgment that threatened their professional pride and authority. Thus, their collective resistance to implementing a beneficial policy reveals The Hidden Incentives Behind Human Behavior, especially when such behavior perpetuates adverse outcomes that might otherwise be easily prevented.
This same dynamic can also be seen in the authors’ discussion of the unintended consequences of the introduction of seat belts. In this case, because drivers wearing seatbelts felt safer behind the wheel, some of them adopted riskier driving habits, potentially negating the safety benefits of seat belts. This example highlights the interplay between perceived security and human tendencies to push boundaries when risks seem mitigated. On a similar note, the “Cobra Effect” vividly captures the fact that poorly designed incentives can backfire spectacularly. When a bounty on cobras incentivized individuals to breed cobras in order to exploit the British bounty system, this consequence revealed the human propensity to game systems when given the opportunity.
On another level, each of Levitt and Dubner’s examples in this chapter show the authors’ appreciation for The Role of Data and Economic Principles in Understanding Societal Issues. They prove that Semmelweis’s success in decreasing the instances of childbed fever stemmed from his rigorous observation and data collection. This reliance on empirical evidence provided a blueprint for modern public health interventions, demonstrating that data can uncover unseen patterns and inform practical solutions.
The analysis of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) further illustrates this theme. Although the ADA aimed to combat workplace discrimination, the economic principle of unintended consequences soon caused unforeseen complications. Some employers, wary of potential legal entanglements, began to avoid hiring disabled workers altogether, and this approach to the new legislation essentially undermined its intended effect. This example shows the importance of anticipating how economic agents—employers, in this case—might adapt to regulations in ways that counteract the intended goals. Additionally, the authors extend this reasoning to environmental legislation, showing that landowners who are faced with habitat regulations often act preemptively to avoid restrictions. In each case, the authors use data and economic reasoning to reveal how these protective measures inadvertently incentivize destructive behavior.
In addition to focusing on individual or community-based issues, this chapter also celebrates unconventional thinking as a means of addressing seemingly insurmountable global challenges. For example, the proposal to mitigate hurricanes using cost-effective devices is intended to show that innovative, out-of-the-box solutions can address complex natural phenomena. By leveraging data on ocean temperatures and storm formation, the solution aligns with the chapter’s broader advocacy for the Application of Unconventional Solutions to Global Challenges.
However, in acknowledgement of the fact that globally oriented solutions are necessarily complex, the authors also stress the importance of thoroughly evaluating potential outcomes before implementing solutions. Semmelweis’s case and the hurricane mitigation strategy both underscore the value of comprehensive thinking, demonstrating that solutions must address the immediate problem and account for quirks of human behavior and unintended consequences. By employing economic principles and data-driven analysis, Levitt and Dubner illuminate the nuanced dynamics behind societal issues, and their advocacy for unconventional solutions champions the role of creativity and critical thinking in tackling global challenges.
Unlock all 49 pages of this Study GuidePlus, gain access to 9,100+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Related Titles
By these authors
